Consider the following thesis for a short paper that analyzes different approaches to stopping climate change:

Climate activism that focuses on personal actions such as recycling obscures the need for systemic change that will be required to slow carbon emissions.

The author of this thesis is promising to make the case that personal actions not only will not solve the climate problem but may actually make the problem more difficult to solve. In order to make a convincing argument, the author will need to consider how thoughtful people might disagree with this claim. In this case, the author might anticipate the following counterarguments:

  • By encouraging personal actions, climate activists may raise awareness of the problem and encourage people to support larger systemic change.  
  • Personal actions on a global level would actually make a difference.  
  • Personal actions may not make a difference, but they will not obscure the need for systemic solutions.  
  • Personal actions cannot be put into one category and must be differentiated.

In order to make a convincing argument, the author of this essay may need to address these potential counterarguments. But you don’t need to address every possible counterargument. Rather, you should engage counterarguments when doing so allows you to strengthen your own argument by explaining how it holds up in relation to other arguments. 

How to address counterarguments 

Once you have considered the potential counterarguments, you will need to figure out how to address them in your essay. In general, to address a counterargument, you’ll need to take the following steps.

  • State the counterargument and explain why a reasonable reader could raise that counterargument.  
  • Counter the counterargument. How you grapple with a counterargument will depend on what you think it means for your argument. You may explain why your argument is still convincing, even in light of this other position. You may point to a flaw in the counterargument. You may concede that the counterargument gets something right but then explain why it does not undermine your argument. You may explain why the counterargument is not relevant. You may refine your own argument in response to the counterargument.  
  • Consider the language you are using to address the counterargument. Words like but or however signal to the reader that you are refuting the counterargument. Words like nevertheless or still signal to the reader that your argument is not diminished by the counterargument. 

Here’s an example of a paragraph in which a counterargument is raised and addressed.

Image version

counter

The two steps are marked with counterargument and “counter” to the counterargument: COUNTERARGUMENT/ But some experts argue that it’s important for individuals to take action to mitigate climate change. In “All That Performative Environmentalism Adds Up,” Annie Lowery argues that personal actions to fight climate change, such as reducing household trash or installing solar panels, matter because change in social behavior can lead to changes in laws. [1]  

COUNTER TO THE COUNTERARGUMENT/ While Lowery may be correct that individual actions can lead to collective action, this focus on individual action can allow corporations to receive positive publicity while continuing to burn fossil fuels at dangerous rates.

Where to address counterarguments 

There is no one right place for a counterargument—where you raise a particular counterargument will depend on how it fits in with the rest of your argument. The most common spots are the following:

  • Before your conclusion This is a common and effective spot for a counterargument because it’s a chance to address anything that you think a reader might still be concerned about after you’ve made your main argument. Don’t put a counterargument in your conclusion, however. At that point, you won’t have the space to address it, and readers may come away confused—or less convinced by your argument.
  • Before your thesis Often, your thesis will actually be a counterargument to someone else’s argument. In other words, you will be making your argument because someone else has made an argument that you disagree with. In those cases, you may want to offer that counterargument before you state your thesis to show your readers what’s at stake—someone else has made an unconvincing argument, and you are now going to make a better one. 
  • After your introduction In some cases, you may want to respond to a counterargument early in your essay, before you get too far into your argument. This is a good option when you think readers may need to understand why the counterargument is not as strong as your argument before you can even launch your own ideas. You might do this in the paragraph right after your thesis. 
  • Anywhere that makes sense  As you draft an essay, you should always keep your readers in mind and think about where a thoughtful reader might disagree with you or raise an objection to an assertion or interpretation of evidence that you are offering. In those spots, you can introduce that potential objection and explain why it does not change your argument. If you think it does affect your argument, you can acknowledge that and explain why your argument is still strong.

[1] Annie Lowery, “All that Performative Environmentalism Adds Up.” The Atlantic . August 31, 2020. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/08/your-tote-bag-can-mak…

  • picture_as_pdf Counterargument

How To Write A Counter Argument in an Essay | Meaning, Examples & Purpose

Chukwudumebi Amadi

  • September 11, 2024
  • Uncategorized

Table of Contents Hide

What is a counter argument, what is the aim of a counter argument, 1. refutation, 2. concession, how to write a counterargument, what is included in a counterargument paragraph, common mistakes to avoid while writing counterarguments, example of a counterargument, faqs on how to write a counterargument, we also recommend.

A counter-argument is a perspective or point of view that contradicts or refutes the opposing argument presented in a persuasive essay, usually to win a debate.

A counterargument makes an essay more persuasive because it shows that the writer has considered multiple sides of the issue and can also help to support their own claim by addressing other opinions.

In this post, we’ll break down everything you need to know about writing a counterargument in an essay. We’ll explore its meaning, share practical examples, and explain why it’s an important part of effective essay writing.

A counterargument is a contrasting or opposing viewpoint. Counterarguments are common in persuasive writing . In argumentation, you strive to persuade an audience of your claim. Claims represent the writer’s major ideas and perspective. In an argumentative essay, you want the readers to believe your claim. To persuade your audience of your claim’s validity, provide evidence-based reasoning.

The counterargument is the opposing viewpoint to the one you are writing about. Include counterarguments in your writing to create a response. In a rebuttal, you explain why your position is stronger than the counterargument.

When adding counterarguments to your essay, you must understand their assertions and reasoning. For example, in an essay on whether teachers should assign homework, you argue that they should not. The counterargument is that teachers should offer homework.

Related Post: How To Write A Counterclaim Like a Pro in Argumentative Writing

There are numerous reasons why you might incorporate counterarguments in your writing. Counterarguments and rebuttals reinforce the overall argument. It may seem contradictory, but outlining and responding to opposing viewpoints strengthens your case.

By embracing and rebutting opposing claims, you call the counterargument into question. If you can effectively answer and rebut your opponents, your argument will appear more believable to your audience than the counterargument.

Second, it will help persuade your audience that your point of view is correct, especially if they are doubtful. Arguments can be either one-sided (no counterarguments or opposing views) or multi-sided (incorporating multiple perspectives).

One-sided arguments function best when the listener already believes your statements and reasoning. Because your audience already believes your notion, you don’t need to spend time debating other views.

A multisided argument involves presenting counterarguments, including rebuttals, and arguing why your stance is stronger. This strategy works best with an audience with various viewpoints since it demonstrates that you understand their thoughts while fighting for your own.

Counterarguments help to persuade your audience that your position is correct. You acknowledge their beliefs while demonstrating why your stance is superior.

How To Address Counter Arguments

Remember that arguments can be one-sided or multisided. If you are writing a multisided argument, you must understand how to address counterarguments based on your audience’s perspectives.

There are numerous approaches to answering counterarguments and developing rebuttals. These methods fall into two primary categories: rebuttal and concession.

SEE ALSO: How to Write a Children’s Picture Book in 12 Simple Steps

Refutation involves demonstrating that a counterargument contains logical fallacies or lacks supporting evidence. Logical fallacies are flaws in reasoning. You can use these logical fallacies to debunk and undermine an argument.

Refutation is an effective method for persuading an audience that may be more sympathetic to your point of view.

There are various techniques to disprove a counterargument.

Identify logical fallacies

When considering a counterargument, take the time to analyze its assertions and arguments. You may see logical flaws in the counterargument, such as incorrect reasoning or overgeneralization. You can address these fallacies in your rebuttal and explain why your argument is stronger.

Point out unstated assumptions made in the argument

In general, arguments frequently include unstated assumptions. For example, assume you’re researching the counterargument that professors should offer homework to help pupils learn academic topics. The idea is that pupils will have enough time at home to complete their tasks. To refute this premise in your argument, include statistics on how pupils do not have enough time to finish assignments.

Find counterexamples or counter-evidence 

Your counterargument will incorporate data and evidence to support your claims. You’ll need to find proof and data to back up your reply. You should use this evidence and data if it calls into question the counterargument’s evidence.

Question the data used to support the counterargument 

Authors will use data and statistics to support their logical claims in an essay. You should investigate the author’s use of this data to see if they properly cited it. If they misinterpreted it or it is out of current, you can address this in your response and provide a more accurate perspective.

Show how the counterargument’s experts or examples are flawed or not valid 

Take the time to find out what sources the author is using. If you discover that a cited expert is not credible on the issue, or that an example is incorrect, you might undermine the counterargument by discussing the lack of credibility of an authority or example. In your argument, provide more compelling and accurate evidence.

READ ALSO: How to Write Up a Bill of Sale: What It Is, Examples, & 6 Steps to Follow

Concession is a rebuttal approach that admits an opposing argument is correct. However, you will demonstrate that your statements are stronger because they are supported by more compelling evidence.

For example, you may write an essay explaining why teachers should not assign homework. You would agree that the research for the homework is correct. However, you would give many pieces of data and explain why this research indicates that teachers should not favor homework.

There are two reasons to include compromises in your writing. For starters, a compromise is an excellent technique if your audience is sympathetic to the opposing viewpoint. Because you recognize the strength of the opposing argument, you will not alienate your audience.

Second, a concession can help your argument. Because you show that the counterargument is strong, you can strengthen your overall argument by providing more compelling evidence for why your stance is correct.

To start writing a counterargument, research the opposing viewpoints. You’ll need to conduct this study to grasp the grounds and claims supporting the opposing position.

This writing focuses on the most important statements and justifications for the opposing position. Begin your counterargument paragraph by summarizing and discussing the claims. Your argument will be more powerful if you can interact and respond to the most compelling information in the counterargument.

After outlining the competing points of view, write the response in the second part of the paragraph. To address the counterargument, use one of the tactics listed above. The counterargument you choose will be determined by your target audience and goals.

Remember, a skeptical audience may find concession more persuasive, while a neutral or supportive audience may support refutation. In the rebuttal, address the specific reasons and claims from the counterargument. You will want to use research to support your rebuttal.

Whether you put the counterargument or your primary argument first depends on your objectives. A counterargument refuted via refutation is typically found near the end of the essay after you have discussed your key claims. After presenting your claims and facts, use them to develop a reply to the counterargument.

Concessions are best used toward the beginning of the document, following the introduction. Because your major points demonstrate how your argument is stronger, you should introduce the opposing position from the start.

READ ALSO: How to Write a Children’s Picture Book in 12 Simple Steps

A counterargument paragraph typically includes the following elements:

  • Presentation of the opposing argument:  Present the opposing argument objectively, giving it equal respect as your own.
  • Refutation:  To successfully refute a counterargument, provide instances, facts, reasoning, and illustrations.
  • Transition to your argument:  Use transitional sentences to take readers from the counterargument to your argument, ensuring coherence and flow.
  • Evidence and reasoning in support of your argument:  After you’ve addressed the counterargument, back up your views with more justification and proof.

It is critical to remember that a counterargument paragraph is not intended to attack the opposing argument, but rather to accept and reply to it. This strengthens your own arguments by demonstrating a broader understanding of the issue and a willingness to consider competing ideas.

Keep these things in mind when you write argumentative essays, and avoid them as much as possible:

  • You haven’t done research on the multiple perspectives on the topic.
  • You don’t include supporting ideas for the positions against your thesis.
  • You dedicate too much space and attention to contradicting reasons.
  • You don’t bring up a different perspective in the introduction but keep to your opinion only.
  • Your line of thought is incoherent, and you constantly switch standpoints throughout the paper.
  • You use offensive or biased language to refute the opponent’s viewpoint.
  •  You believe the opponent’s stance is wrong and don’t give it credit.
  • Besides having a strong argument, you make the counterview weak and ineffective.
  • You can’t explain how your position responds to the contradicting idea.
  • If you aren’t a rhetoric expert, avoid using sarcasm and satire.

SEE ALSO: How To Write Void Check: Uses, Step-by-Step Guide

Main Argument : “Implementing a four-day workweek would improve employee productivity and work-life balance.”

Counterargument Paragraph :

Some may argue that switching to a four-day workweek could negatively impact businesses, particularly in industries that rely on constant customer service or production. Opponents claim that reducing the number of workdays might lead to incomplete tasks and lower customer satisfaction due to delayed responses. However, studies from countries that have adopted shorter workweeks, such as Iceland, show that employees often become more efficient, completing the same amount of work in fewer hours. Additionally, companies can implement staggered shifts or rotating teams to ensure that business operations continue smoothly. By addressing these concerns, the benefits of a four-day workweek—such as increased productivity and employee well-being—far outweigh the potential drawbacks.

A counterargument is a viewpoint that opposes the main argument or position presented in a discussion, essay, or debate. It allows writers to acknowledge opposing perspectives and then refute them with evidence or reasoning.

Including a counterargument boosts your main point by demonstrating that you examined alternative perspectives. It also allows you to rebut such points of view, demonstrating the superiority of your argument and strengthening your viewpoint.

A counterargument begins with an introduction to the opposite viewpoint, followed by evidence supporting it. You next reject the counterargument with logical reasoning or evidence, so reinforcing your original assertion.

A counterargument can appear in different parts of your writing, depending on the structure. Commonly, it’s included after presenting the main argument but before the conclusion. However, in some cases, it may fit naturally within individual paragraphs addressing specific points.

This post helps you understand what is a counterargument and how to write a counterargument. Provided you follow the tips outlined above, it won’t take long to polish your work. If you have any concerns about your writing assignment, always ask your teacher for support.

  • edusson.com – How To Write A Counter Argument In An Essay
  • studysmarter.co.uk – Counter Argument
  • How To Write A Letter To A Friend in 17 Steps: Sample, Format, Example
  • How To Write Void Check: Uses, Step-by-Step Guide
  • How to Write a Children’s Picture Book in 12 Simple Steps

How to Write a Concluding Sentence and 12 Great Examples

How to write a romance novel in 7 easy steps, related posts, how to write punctuality prefect application letter with no experience in nigeria.

  • September 21, 2024
  • August 30, 2024
  • August 27, 2024

How to Write a Counter Argument (Step-by-Step Guide)

Have you been asked to include a counter argument in an essay you are writing? Unless you are already an experienced essay writer, you may have no idea where to even start. We're here to help you tackle your counter argument like a pro.

What Is a Counter Argument?

A counter argument is precisely what it sounds like — an argument that offers reasons to disagree with an essay's thesis statement. As you are writing your essay, you will likely pen multiple supporting arguments that outline precisely why readers should logically agree with the thesis. In a counter argument paragraph, you show that you also understand common reasons to believe differently.

In any given essay, you may write one or more counter arguments — and then, frequently, immediately refute them. Whether you are required to include a counter argument or you simply want to, always include:

  • A simple statement explaining the counter argument. As it will likely follow paragraphs in which you fleshed out your argument, this can start with words like "Some people are concerned that", or "critics say", or "On the other hand".
  • Then include further reasoning, data, or statistics.
  • Following this, you will want to discredit the counter argument immediately.

Why Include a Counter Argument?

Including a counter argument (or multiple, for that matter) in an essay may be required, but even in cases where it is not, mentioning at least one counter argument can make your essay much stronger. You may, at first glance, believe that you are undermining yourself and contradicting your thesis statement. That's not true at all. By including a counter argument in your essay, you show that:

  • You have done your research and are intimately familiar with each aspect of your thesis, including opposition to it.
  • You have arrived at your conclusion through the power of reason, and without undue bias.
  • You do not only blindly support your thesis, but can also deal with opposition to it.

In doing so, your essay will become much more reasoned and logical, and in practical terms, this likely means that you can count on a higher grade.

How To Write a Counter Argument (Step-by-Step Guide)

You have been laboring over your essay for a while, carefully researching each aspect of your thesis and making strong arguments that aim to persuade the reader that your view is the correct one — or at least that you are a solid writer who understands the subject matter and deserves a good grade for your efforts.

If you are passionate about the topic in question, it can be hard to decide how to incorporate a counter argument. Here's how to do it, step-by-step:

1. Brainstorm

You have already researched your topic, so you know on what grounds people most frequently oppose your argument. Write them down. Pick one, or a few, that you consider to be important and interesting. Formulate the counter argument as if you were on the opposing side.

2. Making the Transition

Your counter argument paragraph or paragraphs differ from the rest of your essay, so you will want to introduce a counter argument with a transition. Common ways to do this are to introduce your counter argument with phrases like:

  • Admittedly, conversely, however, nevertheless, or although.
  • Opponents would argue that...
  • Common concerns with this position are...
  • Critics say that...

3. Offering Evidence

Flesh the counter argument out by offering evidence — of the fact that people hold that position (where possible, quote a well-known opponent), as well as reasons why. Word your counter argument in such a way that makes it clear that you have carefully considered the position, and are not simply belittling it. This portion of your counter argument will require doing additional research in most cases.

4. Refute the Counter Argument

You are still arguing in favor of your main thesis. You will, therefore, not just want to describe the opposing side and leave it at that — you will also thoughtfully want to show why the opposing argument is not valid, in your opinion, and you will want to include evidence here, as well.

5. Restate Your Argument

After refuting your counter argument, you can go ahead and restate your argument. Why should people believe what you have to say, despite any opposition?

How To Write A Good Counter Argument

As you're writing a counter argument, you might run into some difficulties if you fervently believe in the truth of your argument. Indeed, in some cases, your argument may appear to you to be so obvious that you don't understand why anyone could think differently.

To help you write a good counter argument, keep in mind that:

  • You should never caricature the opposing viewpoint. Show that you deeply understand it, instead.
  • To do this, it helps if you validate legitimate concerns you find in an opponent's point of view.
  • This may require quite a bit of research, including getting into the opposing side's mindset.
  • Refute your counter argument with compassion, and not smugly.

Examples of Counter Arguments with Refutation

Still not sure? No worries; we have you covered. Take a look at these examples:

  • Many people have argued that a vaccine mandate would strip people of their individual liberties by forcing them to inject foreign substances into their bodies. While this is, in a sense, true, the option of remaining unvaccinated likewise forces other people to be exposed to this virus; thereby potentially stripping them of the most important liberty of all — the liberty to stay alive.
  • The concern has been raised that the death penalty could irreversibly strip innocent people of their lives. The answer to this problem lies in raising the bar for death penalty sentences by limiting them to only those cases in which no question whatsoever exists that the convicted party was truly guilty. Modern forensic science has made this infinitely easier.

In short, you'll want to acknowledge that other arguments exist, and then refute them. The tone in which you do so depends on your goal.

What is a counter argument in a thesis?

A counter argument is one that supports the opposing side. In an essay, it shows that you understand other viewpoints, have considered them, and ultimately dismissed them.

Where do I place the counter argument in an essay?

Place the counter argument after your main supporting arguments.

How long should the counter argument be?

It may be a single paragraph or multiple, depending on how important you believe the counter argument to be and the length of the essay.

What is the difference between a counter argument and a rebuttal?

A counter argument describes the opposing side in some detail before it is refuted. In a rebuttal, you may simply oppose the opposition.

Related posts:

  • How to Write an Effective Claim (with Examples)
  • How To Write A Movie Title In An Essay
  • How to Write a D&D Campaign (Step-by-Step)
  • Bean Counters - Meaning, Origin and Usage
  • I Beg to Differ - Meaning, Origin and Usage
  • Bone of Contention - Meaning, Usage and Origin

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Welcome to the new OASIS website! We have academic skills, library skills, math and statistics support, and writing resources all together in one new home.

should you include a counter argument in an essay

  • Walden University
  • Faculty Portal

Writing a Paper: Responding to Counterarguments

Basics of counterarguments.

When constructing an argument, it is important to consider any counterarguments a reader might make. Acknowledging the opposition shows that you are knowledgeable about the issue and are not simply ignoring other viewpoints. Addressing counterarguments also gives you an opportunity to clarify and strengthen your argument, helping to show how your argument is stronger than other arguments.

Incorporating counterarguments into your writing can seem counterintuitive at first, and some writers may be unsure how to do so. To help you incorporate counterarguments into your argument, we recommend following the steps: (a) identify, (b) investigate, (c) address, and (d) refine.

Identify the Counterarguments

First you need to identify counterarguments to your own argument. Ask yourself, based on your argument, what might someone who disagrees counter in response? You might also discover counterarguments while doing your research, as you find authors who may disagree with your argument.

For example, if you are researching the current opioid crisis in the United States, your argument might be: State governments should allocate part of the budget for addiction recovery centers in communities heavily impacted by the opioid crisis . A few counterarguments might be:

  • Recovery centers are not proven to significantly help people with addiction.
  • The state’s money should go to more pressing concerns such as...
  • Establishing and maintaining a recovery center is too costly.
  • Addicts are unworthy of assistance from the state. 

Investigate the Counterarguments

Analyze the counterarguments so that you can determine whether they are valid. This may require assessing the counterarguments with the research you already have or by identifying logical fallacies . You may also need to do additional research.

In the above list, the first three counterarguments can be researched. The fourth is a moral argument and therefore can only be addressed in a discussion of moral values, which is usually outside the realm of social science research. To investigate the first, you could do a search for research that studies the effectiveness of recovery centers. For the second, you could look at the top social issues in states around the country. Is the opioid crisis the main concern or are there others? For the third, you could look for public financial data from a recovery center or interview someone who works at one to get a sense of the costs involved. 

Address the Counterarguments

Address one or two counterarguments in a rebuttal. Now that you have researched the counterarguments, consider your response. In your essay, you will need to state and refute these opposing views to give more credence to your argument. No matter how you decide to incorporate the counterargument into your essay, be sure you do so with objectivity, maintaining a formal and scholarly tone . 

Considerations when writing:

  • Will you discredit the counteragument by bringing in contradictory research?
  • Will you concede that the point is valid but that your argument still stands as the better view? (For example, perhaps it is very costly to run a recovery center, but the societal benefits offset that financial cost.)
  • Placement . You can choose to place the counterargument toward the beginning of the essay, as a way to anticipate opposition, or you can place it toward the end of the essay, after you have solidly made the main points of your argument. You can also weave a counterargument into a body paragraph, as a way to quickly acknowledge opposition to a main point. Which placement is best depends on your argument, how you’ve organized your argument, and what placement you think is most effective.
  • Weight . After you have addressed the counterarguments, scan your essay as a whole. Are you spending too much time on them in comparison to your main points? Keep in mind that if you linger too long on the counterarguments, your reader might learn less about your argument and more about opposing viewpoints instead. 

Refine Your Argument

Considering counterarguments should help you refine your own argument, clarifying the relevant issues and your perspective. Furthermore, if you find yourself agreeing with the counterargument, you will need to revise your thesis statement and main points to reflect your new thinking. 

Templates for Responding to Counterarguments

There are many ways you can incorporate counterarguments, but remember that you shouldn’t just mention the counterargument—you need to respond to it as well. You can use these templates (adapted from Graff & Birkenstein, 2009) as a starting point for responding to counterarguments in your own writing.

  • The claim that _____ rests upon the questionable assumption that _____.
  • X may have been true in the past, but recent research has shown that ________.
  • By focusing on _____, X has overlooked the more significant problem of _____.
  • Although I agree with X up to a point, I cannot accept the overall conclusion that _____.
  • Though I concede that _____, I still insist that _____.
  • Whereas X has provided ample evidence that ____, Y and Z’s research on ____ and ____ convinces me that _____ instead.
  • Although I grant that _____, I still maintain that _____.
  • While it is true that ____, it does not necessarily follow that _____.

Graff, G., & Birkenstein, C. (2009). They say/I say: The moves that matter in academic writing (2 nd ed.). Norton.

Didn't find what you need? Email us at [email protected] .

  • Previous Page: Addressing Assumptions
  • Next Page: Revising
  • Office of Student Disability Services

Walden Resources

Departments.

  • Academic Residencies
  • Academic Skills
  • Career Planning and Development
  • Customer Care Team
  • Field Experience
  • Military Services
  • Student Success Advising
  • Writing Skills

Centers and Offices

  • Center for Social Change
  • Office of Academic Support and Instructional Services
  • Office of Degree Acceleration
  • Office of Research and Doctoral Services
  • Office of Student Affairs

Student Resources

  • Doctoral Writing Assessment
  • Form & Style Review
  • Quick Answers
  • ScholarWorks
  • SKIL Courses and Workshops
  • Walden Bookstore
  • Walden Catalog & Student Handbook
  • Student Safety/Title IX
  • Legal & Consumer Information
  • Website Terms and Conditions
  • Cookie Policy
  • Accessibility
  • Accreditation
  • State Authorization
  • Net Price Calculator
  • Cost of Attendance
  • Contact Walden

Walden University is a member of Adtalem Global Education, Inc. www.adtalem.com Walden University is certified to operate by SCHEV © 2024 Walden University LLC. All rights reserved.

logo for Englishcurrent.com, an ESL website

English Current

ESL Lesson Plans, Tests, & Ideas

  • North American Idioms
  • Business Idioms
  • Idioms Quiz
  • Idiom Requests
  • Proverbs Quiz & List
  • Phrasal Verbs Quiz
  • Basic Phrasal Verbs
  • North American Idioms App
  • A(n)/The: Help Understanding Articles
  • The First & Second Conditional
  • The Difference between 'So' & 'Too'
  • The Difference between 'a few/few/a little/little'
  • The Difference between "Other" & "Another"
  • Check Your Level
  • English Vocabulary
  • Verb Tenses (Intermediate)
  • Articles (A, An, The) Exercises
  • Prepositions Exercises
  • Irregular Verb Exercises
  • Gerunds & Infinitives Exercises
  • Discussion Questions
  • Speech Topics
  • Argumentative Essay Topics
  • Top-rated Lessons
  • Intermediate
  • Upper-Intermediate
  • Reading Lessons
  • View Topic List
  • Expressions for Everyday Situations
  • Travel Agency Activity
  • Present Progressive with Mr. Bean
  • Work-related Idioms
  • Adjectives to Describe Employees
  • Writing for Tone, Tact, and Diplomacy
  • Speaking Tactfully
  • Advice on Monetizing an ESL Website
  • Teaching your First Conversation Class
  • How to Teach English Conversation
  • Teaching Different Levels
  • Teaching Grammar in Conversation Class
  • Members' Home
  • Update Billing Info.
  • Cancel Subscription
  • North American Proverbs Quiz & List
  • North American Idioms Quiz
  • Idioms App (Android)
  • 'Be used to'" / 'Use to' / 'Get used to'
  • Ergative Verbs and the Passive Voice
  • Keywords & Verb Tense Exercises
  • Irregular Verb List & Exercises
  • Non-Progressive (State) Verbs
  • Present Perfect vs. Past Simple
  • Present Simple vs. Present Progressive
  • Past Perfect vs. Past Simple
  • Subject Verb Agreement
  • The Passive Voice
  • Subject & Object Relative Pronouns
  • Relative Pronouns Where/When/Whose
  • Commas in Adjective Clauses
  • A/An and Word Sounds
  • 'The' with Names of Places
  • Understanding English Articles
  • Article Exercises (All Levels)
  • Yes/No Questions
  • Wh-Questions
  • How far vs. How long
  • Affect vs. Effect
  • A few vs. few / a little vs. little
  • Boring vs. Bored
  • Compliment vs. Complement
  • Die vs. Dead vs. Death
  • Expect vs. Suspect
  • Experiences vs. Experience
  • Go home vs. Go to home
  • Had better vs. have to/must
  • Have to vs. Have got to
  • I.e. vs. E.g.
  • In accordance with vs. According to
  • Lay vs. Lie
  • Make vs. Do
  • In the meantime vs. Meanwhile
  • Need vs. Require
  • Notice vs. Note
  • 'Other' vs 'Another'
  • Pain vs. Painful vs. In Pain
  • Raise vs. Rise
  • So vs. Such
  • So vs. So that
  • Some vs. Some of / Most vs. Most of
  • Sometimes vs. Sometime
  • Too vs. Either vs. Neither
  • Weary vs. Wary
  • Who vs. Whom
  • While vs. During
  • While vs. When
  • Wish vs. Hope
  • 10 Common Writing Mistakes
  • 34 Common English Mistakes
  • First & Second Conditionals
  • Comparative & Superlative Adjectives
  • Determiners: This/That/These/Those
  • Check Your English Level
  • Grammar Quiz (Advanced)
  • Vocabulary Test - Multiple Questions
  • Vocabulary Quiz - Choose the Word
  • Verb Tense Review (Intermediate)
  • Verb Tense Exercises (All Levels)
  • Conjunction Exercises
  • List of Topics
  • Business English
  • Games for the ESL Classroom
  • Pronunciation
  • Teaching Your First Conversation Class
  • How to Teach English Conversation Class

Argumentative Essays: The Counter-Argument & Refutation

An argumentative essay presents an argument for or against a topic. For example, if your topic is working from home , then your essay would either argue in favor of working from home (this is the for  side) or against working from home.

Like most essays, an argumentative essay begins with an introduction that ends with the writer's position (or stance) in the thesis statement .

Introduction Paragraph

(Background information....)

  • Thesis statement : Employers should give their workers the option to work from home in order to improve employee well-being and reduce office costs.

This thesis statement shows that the two points I plan to explain in my body paragraphs are 1) working from home improves well-being, and 2) it allows companies to reduce costs. Each topic will have its own paragraph. Here's an example of a very basic essay outline with these ideas:

  • Background information

Body Paragraph 1

  • Topic Sentence : Workers who work from home have improved well-being .
  • Evidence from academic sources

Body Paragraph 2

  • Topic Sentence : Furthermore, companies can reduce their expenses by allowing employees to work at home .
  • Summary of key points
  • Restatement of thesis statement

Does this look like a strong essay? Not really . There are no academic sources (research) used, and also...

You Need to Also Respond to the Counter-Arguments!

The above essay outline is very basic. The argument it presents can be made much stronger if you consider the counter-argument , and then try to respond (refute) its points.

The counter-argument presents the main points on the other side of the debate. Because we are arguing FOR working from home, this means the counter-argument is AGAINST working from home. The best way to find the counter-argument is by reading research on the topic to learn about the other side of the debate. The counter-argument for this topic might include these points:

  • Distractions at home > could make it hard to concentrate
  • Dishonest/lazy people > might work less because no one is watching

Next, we have to try to respond to the counter-argument in the refutation (or rebuttal/response) paragraph .

The Refutation/Response Paragraph

The purpose of this paragraph is to address the points of the counter-argument and to explain why they are false, somewhat false, or unimportant. So how can we respond to the above counter-argument? With research !

A study by Bloom (2013) followed workers at a call center in China who tried working from home for nine months. Its key results were as follows:

  • The performance of people who worked from home increased by 13%
  • These workers took fewer breaks and sick-days
  • They also worked more minutes per shift

In other words, this study shows that the counter-argument might be false. (Note: To have an even stronger essay, present data from more than one study.) Now we have a refutation.

Where Do We Put the Counter-Argument and Refutation?

Commonly, these sections can go at the beginning of the essay (after the introduction), or at the end of the essay (before the conclusion). Let's put it at the beginning. Now our essay looks like this:

Counter-argument Paragraph

  • Dishonest/lazy people might work less because no one is watching

Refutation/Response Paragraph

  • Study: Productivity  increased by 14%
  • (+ other details)

Body Paragraph 3

  • Topic Sentence : In addition, people who work from home have improved well-being .

Body Paragraph 4

The outline is stronger now because it includes the counter-argument and refutation. Note that the essay still needs more details and research to become more convincing.

Working from home

Working from home may increase productivity.

Extra Advice on Argumentative Essays

It's not a compare and contrast essay.

An argumentative essay focuses on one topic (e.g. cats) and argues for or against it. An argumentative essay should not have two topics (e.g. cats vs dogs). When you compare two ideas, you are writing a compare and contrast essay. An argumentative essay has one topic (cats). If you are FOR cats as pets, a simplistic outline for an argumentative essay could look something like this:

  • Thesis: Cats are the best pet.
  • are unloving
  • cause allergy issues
  • This is a benefit >  Many working people do not have time for a needy pet
  • If you have an allergy, do not buy a cat.
  • But for most people (without allergies), cats are great
  • Supporting Details

Use Language in Counter-Argument That Shows Its Not Your Position

The counter-argument is not your position. To make this clear, use language such as this in your counter-argument:

  • Opponents might argue that cats are unloving.
  • People who dislike cats would argue that cats are unloving.
  • Critics of cats could argue that cats are unloving.
  • It could be argued that cats are unloving.

These  underlined phrases make it clear that you are presenting  someone else's argument , not your own.

Choose the Side with the Strongest Support

Do not choose your side based on your own personal opinion. Instead, do some research and learn the truth about the topic. After you have read the arguments for and against, choose the side with the strongest support as your position.

Do Not Include Too Many Counter-arguments

Include the main (two or three) points in the counter-argument. If you include too many points, refuting these points becomes quite difficult.

If you have any questions, leave a comment below.

- Matthew Barton / Creator of Englishcurrent.com

Additional Resources :

  • Writing a Counter-Argument & Refutation (Richland College)
  • Language for Counter-Argument and Refutation Paragraphs (Brown's Student Learning Tools)

EnglishCurrent is happily hosted on Dreamhost . If you found this page helpful, consider a donation to our hosting bill to show your support!

25 comments on “ Argumentative Essays: The Counter-Argument & Refutation ”

Thank you professor. It is really helpful.

Can you also put the counter argument in the third paragraph

It depends on what your instructor wants. Generally, a good argumentative essay needs to have a counter-argument and refutation somewhere. Most teachers will probably let you put them anywhere (e.g. in the start, middle, or end) and be happy as long as they are present. But ask your teacher to be sure.

Thank you for the information Professor

how could I address a counter argument for “plastic bags and its consumption should be banned”?

For what reasons do they say they should be banned? You need to address the reasons themselves and show that these reasons are invalid/weak.

Thank you for this useful article. I understand very well.

Thank you for the useful article, this helps me a lot!

Thank you for this useful article which helps me in my study.

Thank you, professor Mylene 102-04

it was very useful for writing essay

Very useful reference body support to began writing a good essay. Thank you!

Really very helpful. Thanks Regards Mayank

Thank you, professor, it is very helpful to write an essay.

It is really helpful thank you

It was a very helpful set of learning materials. I will follow it and use it in my essay writing. Thank you, professor. Regards Isha

Thanks Professor

This was really helpful as it lays the difference between argumentative essay and compare and contrast essay.. Thanks for the clarification.

This is such a helpful guide in composing an argumentative essay. Thank you, professor.

This was really helpful proof, thankyou!

Thanks this was really helpful to me

This was very helpful for us to generate a good form of essay

thank you so much for this useful information.

Thank you so much, Sir. This helps a lot!

Thank you for the information l have learnt a lot.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

should you include a counter argument in an essay

Your version of Internet Explorer is either running in "Compatibility View" or is too outdated to display this site. If you believe your version of Internet Explorer is up to date, please remove this site from Compatibility View by opening Tools > Compatibility View settings (IE11) or clicking the broken page icon in your address bar (IE9, IE10)

should you include a counter argument in an essay

Missouri S&T Missouri S&T

  • Future Students
  • Current Students
  • Faculty and Staff
  • writingcenter.mst.edu
  • Online Resources
  • Writing Guides
  • Counter Arguments

Writing and Communication Center

  • 314 Curtis Laws Wilson Library, 400 W 14th St Rolla, MO 65409 United States
  • (573) 341-4436
  • [email protected]

Counter Argument

One way to strengthen your argument and demonstrate a comprehensive understanding of the issue you are discussing is to anticipate and address counter arguments, or objections. By considering opposing views, you show that you have thought things through, and you dispose of some of the reasons your audience might have for not accepting your argument. Ask yourself what someone who disagrees with you might say in response to each of the points you’ve made or about your position as a whole.

If you can’t immediately imagine another position, here are some strategies to try:

  • Do some research. It may seem to you that no one could possibly disagree with the position you are taking, but someone probably has. Look around to see what stances people have and do take on the subject or argument you plan to make, so that you know what environment you are addressing.
  • Talk with a friend or with your instructor. Another person may be able to play devil’s advocate and suggest counter arguments that haven’t occurred to you.
  • Consider each of your supporting points individually. Even if you find it difficult to see why anyone would disagree with your central argument, you may be able to imagine more easily how someone could disagree with the individual parts of your argument. Then you can see which of these counter arguments are most worth considering. For example, if you argued “Cats make the best pets. This is because they are clean and independent,” you might imagine someone saying “Cats do not make the best pets. They are dirty and demanding.”

Once you have considered potential counter arguments, decide how you might respond to them: Will you concede that your opponent has a point but explain why your audience should nonetheless accept your argument? Or will you reject the counterargument and explain why it is mistaken? Either way, you will want to leave your reader with a sense that your argument is stronger than opposing arguments.

Two strategies are available to incorporate counter arguments into your essay:

Refutation:

Refutation seeks to disprove opposing arguments by pointing out their weaknesses. This approach is generally most effective if it is not hostile or sarcastic; with methodical, matter-of-fact language, identify the logical, theoretical, or factual flaws of the opposition.

For example, in an essay supporting the reintroduction of wolves into western farmlands, a writer might refute opponents by challenging the logic of their assumptions:

Although some farmers have expressed concern that wolves might pose a threat to the safety of sheep, cattle, or even small children, their fears are unfounded. Wolves fear humans even more than humans fear wolves and will trespass onto developed farmland only if desperate for food. The uninhabited wilderness that will become the wolves’ new home has such an abundance of food that there is virtually no chance that these shy animals will stray anywhere near humans.

Here, the writer acknowledges the opposing view (wolves will endanger livestock and children) and refutes it (the wolves will never be hungry enough to do so).

Accommodation:

Accommodation acknowledges the validity of the opposing view, but argues that other considerations outweigh it. In other words, this strategy turns the tables by agreeing (to some extent) with the opposition.

For example, the writer arguing for the reintroduction of wolves might accommodate the opposing view by writing:

Critics of the program have argued that reintroducing wolves is far too expensive a project to be considered seriously at this time. Although the reintroduction program is costly, it will only become more costly the longer it is put on hold. Furthermore, wolves will help control the population of pest animals in the area, saving farmers money on extermination costs. Finally, the preservation of an endangered species is worth far more to the environment and the ecological movement than the money that taxpayers would save if this wolf relocation initiative were to be abandoned.

This writer acknowledges the opposing position (the program is too expensive), agrees (yes, it is expensive), and then argues that despite the expense the program is worthwhile.

Some Final Hints

Don’t play dirty. When you summarize opposing arguments, be charitable. Present each argument fairly and objectively, rather than trying to make it look foolish. You want to convince your readers that you have carefully considered all sides of the issues and that you are not simply attacking or caricaturing your opponents.

Sometimes less is more. It is usually better to consider one or two serious counter arguments in some depth, rather than to address every counterargument.

Keep an open mind. Be sure that your reply is consistent with your original argument. Careful consideration of counter arguments can complicate or change your perspective on an issue. There’s nothing wrong with adopting a different perspective or changing your mind, but if you do, be sure to revise your thesis accordingly.

Counterarguments

A counterargument involves acknowledging standpoints that go against your argument and then re-affirming your argument. This is typically done by stating the opposing side’s argument, and then ultimately presenting your argument as the most logical solution. The counterargument is a standard academic move that is used in argumentative essays because it shows the reader that you are capable of understanding and respecting multiple sides of an argument.

Counterargument in two steps

Respectfully acknowledge evidence or standpoints that differ from your argument.

Refute the stance of opposing arguments, typically utilizing words like “although” or “however.”

In the refutation, you want to show the reader why your position is more correct than the opposing idea.

Where to put a counterargument

Can be placed within the introductory paragraph to create a contrast for the thesis statement.

May consist of a whole paragraph that acknowledges the opposing view and then refutes it.

  • Can be one sentence acknowledgements of other opinions followed by a refutation.

Why use a counterargument?

Some students worry that using a counterargument will take away from their overall argument, but a counterargument may make an essay more persuasive because it shows that the writer has considered multiple sides of the issue. Barnet and Bedau (2005) propose that critical thinking is enhanced through imagining both sides of an argument. Ultimately, an argument is strengthened through a counterargument.

Examples of the counterargument structure

  • Argument against smoking on campus:  Admittedly, many students would like to smoke on campus. Some people may rightly argue that if smoking on campus is not illegal, then it should be permitted; however, second-hand smoke may cause harm to those who have health issues like asthma, possibly putting them at risk.
  • Argument against animal testing:  Some people argue that using animals as test subjects for health products is justifiable. To be fair, animal testing has been used in the past to aid the development of several vaccines, such as small pox and rabies. However, animal testing for beauty products causes unneeded pain to animals. There are alternatives to animal testing. Instead of using animals, it is possible to use human volunteers. Additionally, Carl Westmoreland (2006) suggests that alternative methods to animal research are being developed; for example, researchers are able to use skin constructed from cells to test cosmetics. If alternatives to animal testing exist, then the practice causes unnecessary animal suffering and should not be used.

Harvey, G. (1999). Counterargument. Retrieved from writingcenter.fas.harvard.edu/pages/counter- argument

Westmoreland, C. (2006; 2007). “Alternative Tests and the 7th Amendment to the Cosmetics Directive.” Hester, R. E., & Harrison, R. M. (Ed.) Alternatives to animal testing (1st Ed.). Cambridge: Royal Society of Chemistry.

Barnet, S., Bedau, H. (Eds.). (2006). Critical thinking, reading, and writing . Boston, MA: Bedford/St. Martin’s.

Contributor: Nathan Lachner

Del Mar College

Argumentative Writing: The Counterargument

The counterargument is one of the most important parts of an argumentative essay because it can persuade undecided readers. A strong counterargument presents the other side’s point of view, gives an explanation of the reasoning for this view, and then soundly rejects the opposing argument. There are a few key things to keep in mind while drafting a counterargument.

Be Fair to the Other Side

Effective argumentative writing completely refutes any opposing argument, which can only be done when the writer shows an understanding of the opposition’s ideas. If you convince your audience that you understand your opposition’s stance, they will be more likely to listen when you explain why you disagree with the opposing point of view. After all, by fairly covering the opposing side, you show your expertise on the topic and your willingness to reason with the opposition.

Present and Reject the Opposition’s Argument

In addition to presenting the argument of the opposing side, your counterargument should also reject those claims. Simply laying out the other side’s argument and then going back to your own views may not be convincing enough because, although you are giving the opposition a voice in your paper, you are not explaining why they are incorrect. By explaining and rejecting the opposing side’s point of view, you can help convince your reader to see yours.

Example of a Counterargument

If a writer was trying to argue that cookie cake is a valid dessert option for celebrating birthdays, the opposing side might say cookie cake is not a special enough dessert to celebrate birthdays. The opposition would point out that cookies are eaten year-round, so they are not associated with special occasions. To effectively argue that cookie cake is a valid option for birthday celebrations, the writer needs to address and reject the opposition’s argument.

A possible counterargument in which this writer addresses and rejects the opposition might look like:

“Despite the favorable qualities of cookie cake, many would argue that it is not a special enough dessert to celebrate a birthday, since cookies are eaten year-round. Those who do not view cookie cake as a valid birthday dessert option claim that traditional cake is typically eaten only at special events, such as birthdays, which only happen once a year. However, while it is true cookies are eaten year-round, cookie cake is not. Although somewhat similar in taste, cookies and cookie cake are different in texture and presentation. In comparison, these differences are greater than those between cupcakes and cake, which are similar in both taste and texture; just like cookies, cupcakes are eaten outside of special events and can often be found at less formal social gatherings. Despite cupcakes being very similar in taste to cake, the two are considered different in large part due to presentation. If cake can still be considered a special dessert despite cupcakes being commonplace, the same should be true for cookie cake and cookies.”

In lengthier writing, such as an essay, the writer would likely elaborate on the thoughts of the opposition and the rejection of that argument; however, this is a good start to a counterargument. The writer fairly presents the opposing side’s view on why cookie cake should not be used as a birthday dessert, and by taking the time to understand and write out that argument, the writer found a way to refute the claims. This practice allows readers to consider the counterargument and be even more convinced of the writer’s claim that cookie cake should be accepted as a valid option for birthday celebrations.

Page last updated July 12, 2023.

IMAGES

  1. How To Write An Efficient Counter Argument In A Few Simple Steps

    should you include a counter argument in an essay

  2. FREE 8+ Counter Argument Samples in PDF

    should you include a counter argument in an essay

  3. 🌷 Counter argument topics. Counter Argument Example: How to Write an

    should you include a counter argument in an essay

  4. PPT

    should you include a counter argument in an essay

  5. Counter Argument

    should you include a counter argument in an essay

  6. FREE 8+ Counter Argument Samples in PDF

    should you include a counter argument in an essay

VIDEO

  1. Success in Planning I Arguments & Counterarguments

  2. Written Statement, Counter, Written Argument

  3. Is Politics Impossible if Everyone is a Narcissist?

  4. Classic Argument Essay Instructions

  5. IELTS WRITING TASK 2: How to structure an argument

  6. How to Write an Epilogue (should you?)

COMMENTS

  1. Counterargument | Harvard College Writing Center

    A counterargument shouldnt be something you add to your essay after you’ve finished it just because you know you’re supposed to include one. Instead, as you write your essay, you should always be thinking about points where a thoughtful reader could reasonably disagree with you.

  2. The Writing Center | All About Counterarguments | General...

    With a counterargument, you have an opportunity to acknowledge and respond to any objections from the opposition, giving you the advantage since the response comes from you. Usage of a counterargument also demonstrates that you’re a rational and fair arguer who is well-versed in your issue since you acknowledge both sides of the argument.

  3. Writing a Counterargument Paragraph | UAGC Writing Center

    Including a counterargument paragraph when writing an argumentative paper shows your reader you know and understand that other positions exist, you have considered these, and you can respond to them. Doing this gives you credibility and can strengthen your own argument.

  4. How To Write A Counter Argument in an Essay | Meaning ...

    In an argumentative essay, you want the readers to believe your claim. To persuade your audience of your claim’s validity, provide evidence-based reasoning. The counterargument is the opposing viewpoint to the one you are writing about. Include counterarguments in your writing to create a response.

  5. How to Write a Counter Argument (Step-by-Step Guide)

    A counter argument is precisely what it sounds like — an argument that offers reasons to disagree with an essay's thesis statement. As you are writing your essay, you will likely pen multiple supporting arguments that outline precisely why readers should logically agree with the thesis.

  6. Academic Guides: Writing a Paper: Responding to Counterarguments

    When constructing an argument, it is important to consider any counterarguments a reader might make. Acknowledging the opposition shows that you are knowledgeable about the issue and are not simply ignoring other viewpoints.

  7. Argumentative Essays: The Counter-Argument & Refutation

    Generally, a good argumentative essay needs to have a counter-argument and refutation somewhere. Most teachers will probably let you put them anywhere (e.g. in the start, middle, or end) and be happy as long as they are present.

  8. Counter Arguments – Writing and Communication Center ...

    Two strategies are available to incorporate counter arguments into your essay: Refutation: Refutation seeks to disprove opposing arguments by pointing out their weaknesses.

  9. Counterarguments | University Writing & Speaking Center

    A counterargument involves acknowledging standpoints that go against your argument and then re-affirming your argument. This is typically done by stating the opposing side’s argument, and then ultimately presenting your argument as the most logical solution.

  10. Argumentative Writing: The Counterargument - Del Mar College

    The counterargument is one of the most important parts of an argumentative essay because it can persuade undecided readers. A strong counterargument presents the other side’s point of view, gives an explanation of the reasoning for this view, and then soundly rejects the opposing argument.